Monthly Archive for December, 2009

The Jesus of Postmodernism Has No Address

mailboxNot long ago I was out on visitation to visit a family who had recently visited the church.  But before I went out I used “Google Earth” to locate the address and print out a map.  I even went so far as to zoom in on the earth map to get an idea of what their house looked like.  I was confident I knew where to  go and had the right address.  That night it was raining and seemed especially dark.  But I was sure that between my research, printed directions, and GPS navigation I would find the right address.  I was really proud of myself for thinking ahead as I headed out that evening.   I just knew I would find the address and arrive on time for my visit with the new family.  All was going well until I came within striking distance of success.  As I was approaching their house, in the rain, I miss read a street sign and turned down the wrong street.  Even my GPS could not help at this point because I was so close.  But the house at the address I pulled up to didn’t look anything like the picture I had seen on “Google Earth.”  I was now a bit confused but proceeded to get out of my car and walk up the drive way for the visit.  Part way up my doubts grew stronger so I turned around and walked back down the driveway and up to the street corner to double check the street address.  I was on the wrong street!  The street I needed was a couple hundred feet away.

I wonder what would have happened if I had applied postmodern epistemology?  For the postmodernist there is no absolute objective truth.  Would the folks answering the door on the wrong street address have said, “Come on in, we’re as good as the folks a block away.  We’re just like them.”  Hmmm… I wonder how the family I was supposed to visit and was waiting for me would have taken that concept of truth upon my non-arrival?

But for many evangelicals that is exactly how we approach Christ.  For the postmodernist evangelical it is all about relationship and objective truth is unnecessary.   William H. Willimon of Duke University in the 1996, March 4th issue of “Christianity Today, pp 21-22, makes exactly that argument.  Evangelicals, according to Willimon, “are making a tactical mistake.”  “…Jesus did not arrive among us enunciating a set of propositions that we are to affirm.”  He suggests that Jesus came inviting us to follow Him.  But just exactly how are to follow Christ if we have no information about Him that is based on reality and objective truth?  For Willimon it was not important that a person understand or hold to any propositional truths concerning Jesus which might be characterized as objective truth.  With that kind of logic the Jesus of Mormonism or Islam will do nicely.  And of course this kind of logic has also extended itself to the authority of the Scriptures.  For the postmodernist Christian, the bible is authoritative simply because “the community of faith” has granted it this status, not because the Scripture claim to be the infallible, inerrant word of God and authoritative within its self.
Continue reading ‘The Jesus of Postmodernism Has No Address’

Quote Of The Day

Blaise_pascal“It is as much a crime to disturb the peace when truth prevails as it is to keep the peace when truth is violated.  There is therefore a time in which peace is justified and another time when it is not justifiable. For it is written that there is a time for peace and a time for war and it is the law of truth that distinguishes the two.  But at no time is there a time for truth and a time for error, for it is written that God’s truth shall abide forever.  That is why Christ has said that He has come to bring peace and at the same time that He has come to bring the sword.  But He does not say that He has come to bring both the truth and falsehood.”

~Blaise Pascal, (1623-1662), cited in Dietrich von Hildebrand, “The Charitable Anathema”

The Security Of The Believer – What It Is Not!

Matthew 7:21-23 ( NKJV ) 21“Not everyone who says to Me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ shall enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of My Father in heaven.  22Many will say to Me in that day, ‘Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in Your name, cast out demons in Your name, and done many wonders in Your name?’  23And then I will declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from Me, you who practice lawlessness!’

2 Corinthians 13:5 ( NKJV ) 5Examine yourselves as to whether you are in the faith. Test yourselves. Do you not know yourselves, that Jesus Christ is in you?—unless indeed you are disqualified.

waterfallFor me, there is no more glorious a thought than to know that I rest in the saving hands of God (John 1:28).  And for many years I rested in this one solid dimension of God’s faithful grace until, while reading Romans 9:4-13 I saw that the elective purposes of God stood as the foundational and paramount truth to my position in Christ.  I realized that when we are told that it “is not of works but of Him who calls” (vs.11), I stood solely by the grace of God and that “not of works” meant exactly that.  I saw new and afresh that I was saved “to the praise of the glory of His grace” (Ephesians 1:4), and “that in the ages to come He might show the exceeding riches of His grace in His kindness toward us in Christ Jesus” (Ephesians 2:7).

But the “exceeding grace” of God found in the gospel has been co-opted by a gospel message that proclaims;”You don’t have to give up anything, come as you are.”  It is a gospel message that bases it invitation on; “Ask Jesus into your heart,” or ”Invite Christ into your life”, and even worse; “God has a wonderful plan for your life.”  In each of these statements, including the first double phrased statement, there is a measure of truth but if they stand alone they are completely and wholly inadequate and often base the gospel  invitation solely on the perceived benefits accruing to the hearer. It is a gospel message for the welfare of men and not preeminently to the glory of God.  The emphasis on the saviorhood of Christ  is purely relational and ignores or plays down sin and is silent regarding  Jesus as Lord of the life.  Christ is not divided (I Corinthians 1:13).  He is savior and Lord.  The modern gospel message calls the lost to Christ without addressing sin, the depravity of man and the true nature of justification that sees it as a result of regeneration leading to sanctification.  James Montgomery Boice in his preface to MacArthur’s book, “The Gospel According to Jesus Christ states;
Continue reading ‘The Security Of The Believer – What It Is Not!’

Quote Of The Day

2 Timothy 2:19 ( NKJV ) 19Nevertheless the solid foundation of God stands, having this seal: “The Lord knows those who are His,” and, “Let everyone who names the name of £Christ depart from iniquity.”

“We are as birds upon the boughs, and set forth as a prey to Satan.  What assurance then could we have of tomorrow, and of all our life; yea, and after death, were it not that God, who hath called us, will end His work as He hath begun it.  How hath He gathered us together in the faith of His gospel?  Is it grounded upon us?  Nay, entirely to the contrary; it proceedeth from His free election.  Therefore: we may be so much the more freed from doubt.”

~John Calvin, “The Mystery Of Godliness and Other Sermons,” (1830; repr. Morgan, PA: Soli Deo Gloria, 1999), pg 104-104

Security of the Believer and Spurgeon

I had hoped to finish a post called “The Security of the Believer-What It Is Not!”  To many interruptions…  But as I researched I thought I would leave you with this from the “Prince of Preachers,” Charles Hadden Spurgeon.

“Another proof of the conquest of a soul for Christ will be found in a real change of life.  If thespurgeon1 man does not live differently from what he did before, both at home and abroad, his repentance needs to be repented of, and his conversion is a fiction.  Not only action and language, but spirit and temper must be changed. … Abiding under the power of any known sin is a mark of our being the servants of sin, for ‘his servants yea are to whom ye obey.’  Idle are the boasts of a man who harbors within himself the love of any transgression.  He may feel what he likes, and believe what he likes, he is still in the gall of bitterness and the bonds of iniquity while a single sin rules his heart and life.  True regeneration implants a hatred of all evil; and where one sin  is delighted in, the evidence is fatal to a sound hope. …

There must be a harmony between the life and the profession.  A Christian professes to renounce sin; and if he does not do so, his very name is an imposture.”

~Charles Hadden Spurgeon, “The Soul Winner” (Pasadena, Texas: Pilgrim, 1978), pp.32-33

Strong words and certainly hated and not compatible with the “easy believism” that is so dominant today within Evangelicalism.  Spurgeon is not speaking of sinless perfection but is arguing that one who is truly regenerated by the Spirit of God is not characterized by a life that is ruled by sin or one that loves sin.

- Michael Holtzinger

Quote Of The Day

Introducing the Sermon on the Mount and the Beatitudes, G. Campbell Morgan writes:

“…But He gets down under the surface, and He corrects man in the realm of his character.  He says “Blessed,” but never a single blessing does He pronounce upon having anything or doing anything; every blessing is pronounced upon being.

When Jesus came to setup a Kingdom, the first thing He said was; It is not a question of what you have, or what you do save in a secondary sense; it is a question of what you are.  …But the true imperialist is the Christian man who recognizes that Jesus was right when He said: Deal with men as to what they are first, then you can touch all other things.”

~ G. Campbell Morgan, “The Gospel According To Matthew”, Fleming H Revel Co., 1969, pg.40

The Security Of The Believer – Intro

1 Peter 1:3-5 ( NKJV ) 3Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who according to His abundant mercy has begotten us again to a living hope through the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead,  4to an inheritance incorruptible and undefiled and that does not fade away, reserved in heaven for you,  5who are kept by the power of God through faith for salvation ready to be revealed in the last time.

jesus-hand“Though the Lord, by electing his people, adopted them as his sons, we, however, see that they do not come into possession of this great good until they are called; but when called, the enjoyment of their election is in some measure communicated to them. For which reason the Spirit which they receive is termed by Paul both the “Spirit of adoption,” and the “seal” and “earnest” of the future inheritance; because by his testimony he confirms and seals the certainty of future adoption on their hearts.” ~ John Calvin, “Institutes of the Christian Religion” 3.24.1, A New Translation, by Henry Beveridge, Esq Volume First Edinburgh: Printed for The Calvin Translation Society M.DCCC.XLV)

It was not long after my conversion that I came to the realization that that which Christ had done in me in salvation was astounding beyond my comprehension. I was an undeserving hopeless sinner, but now an object of God’s grace.  As this light permeated my consciousness the truth that I was now Christ’s workmanship (Ephesians 2:10) to an inheritance that was incorruptible, undefiled, will not fade away and is reserved in heaven, captured my imagination and sent me reveling in gratitude and worship for the “indescribable gift” of Christ (2 Corinthians 9:15).  This, for me stood in stark contrast to my former Roman Catholic understanding.  I was taught that Christ forgave my sins on the cross but did not pay for them. I would have to, in some part, expiate or be punished for my sins (ie. the sacrament of penance, based in part on the Roman Catholic doctrines of mortal and venial sins, and the Roman Catholic doctrine of purgatory to name a few).   In light of the Scriptures I now saw that as totally depraved as I was before my salvation (Romans 3:1-23), I was now just as totally justified because of the merits of Christ on the cross and now stood in a right standing and relationship before God with an alien righteousness, the imputed righteousness of  Christ (2 Corinthians 5:21; Romans 4:3-6,9; 4:4, 9; 5:7,21; 10:4, 10; Philippians 3:9). The doctrine of justification by faith alone (Romans 3:21-26; 5:19) became a precious truth that has for these many years become for me the prince of doctrines that has in great measure defined my life and ministry. I am also convinced that a proper view of justification leads to a right view of the security of the believer and visa versa.

For many in the evangelical world, the security of the believer or as Calvin called it,” the perseverance of the saints” is not essential to a proper understanding of the gospel.  I could not disagree more strongly. We weaken the doctrine of justification with a view that one can lose his or her salvation.  We in essence are saying that the efficacy of the work of Christ on the cross and the declaration of righteousness in justification has its limits. It is to say that there is some action (sin) on our part that can remove us from the grace of God found in Christ Jesus.  Of course this contradicts the clear declaration of Scripture (ie. John 10:27-30; Philippians 1:6). At least for me there is no way to preach the fullness of the gospel without declaring the glorious truth of the security of the believer.

2 Timothy 1:12 ( NKJV ) 12For this reason I also suffer these things; nevertheless I am not ashamed, for I know whom I have believed and am persuaded that He is able to keep what I have committed to Him until that Day.

So for the next several posts I will discuss this glorious truth. My goal here is not to deliver some heady theological discourse but rather to give clear sense to a cardinal truth of the faith once delivered (Jude 3).  I hope it will be a blessing to you as it is for me as I stand in awe of the grace of God.

~Michael Holtzinger

Quote Of The Day

” No matter how many strong enemies plot to overthrow the church, they do not have sufficient strength to prevail over God’s immutable decree by which he appointed his Son eternal King.”

~John Calvin, “Institutes od the Christian Religion”, ed. John T. McNeill: trans. Ford Lewis Battles; Liberty of Christian Classics, XX-XXI (Philadelphia: Westminster John Knox 1960) 2.15.3.

The Little Church That Could…

incarnationalIn the early 70’s I came to know Christ as my Lord and Savior.  These were glorious times as I and many others in the church I attended experienced our early years of discipleship.  The church was in Ashland Oregon.  It was a small church meeting on the outskirts of town.  I can remember before my conversion driving by on many occasions, the church in a storefront, wondering what kind of cult Ashland Bible Church was.   Then one Wednesday evening I found myself getting out of a Sherriff’s patrol car in the parking lot of the church just as the midweek service concluded.  Not exactly the typical entrance one would want or others would expect!  The next several weeks it was amazing how this little congregation accepted me, even with all the trappings of a sinful world most evident in my dress and mannerism.  I would sit each service in the homemade grey plywood pews and was inwardly very critical of the simple services that were offered. The pianist was an eighty+ year old woman, playing very tradition gospel hymns and the pastor was a middle aged man preaching from a very simple one step platform in the front of the auditorium with an 8 foot ceiling and florescent lights.  But I wasn’t alone as the church was in the middle of an influx of young college age, drug using, and commune living hippie types.  What a mix in the middle of this traditional middle class, aging, Bible believing church.  This church existed in a college town that was known for its party atmosphere, occult influence, and as sexually promiscuous.  This little church in no way looked like the culture it was surrounded and immersed in.  It really was to the extreme, counter cultural.  By today’s church growth gurus, Ashland Bible Church was not “incarnational”1 or “missional”2 and certainly didn’t have a grasp of cultural contextualization.   They were a simple people who were astounded and overjoyed at what God was doing in their midst.  They knew nothing of the latest ecclesiastical fads and saw no biblical reason to compromise their holy, separated living for the sake of reaching people for Christ. Yet they reached a group of young people with love and compassion and reaped the fruit of souls saved by the grace of God.

Yet today we are told that unless we can relate with the culture, embrace the culture, be relevant to the culture we are not “missional” and disobedient to the Great Commission  Is it fair criticism to say that the evangelical church is failing in its mission to reach the lost valid?  The answer is yes. Has the church failed to equip a mission minded people who see the context of their personal world a mission field?  The answer is a resounding yes.  But the solution that is being offered in many venues is clearly just as deadly to the spiritual life of the church as the lack of missional zeal is as well.   It is a solution that validates the carnality of the world in the church for the sake of reaching the lost by “embodying” the culture.

Continue reading ‘The Little Church That Could…’

Quote Of The Day

“No one has rightly denied himself unless he has wholly resigned himself to the Lord and is willing to leave every detail to His good pleasure.  If we put ourselves in such a frame of mind, then, whatever may happen to us, we shall never feel miserable or accuse God falsely because of our lot.”

~John Calvin, “Golden Booklet Of The True Christian Life”, trans. Henry J. Van Andel (Grand Rapids: Baker, 1952) pg.44

Transformed – More than Meets the Eye

Romans 12:1-2

An elderly pastor was asked to preach a message at a sister church in a small nearby town.  The occasion was very important.  You see, this church had been meeting in a school, but had just completed building their new sanctuary.  This would be their first Sunday in the building.  The elderly pastor had been asked to preach the dedication service. This was a great honor.

When the elderly preacher began his sermon, he explained to the congregation that while it was important to dedicate their fine building for the Lord’s work, it was even more important to consecrate their lives to Him.

The Apostle Paul wrote to the Roman believers about something very similar.   This was the dedication, or consecration of their lives.  It was his desire that they live their lives sacrificially. Continue reading ‘Transformed – More than Meets the Eye’

Christianity – Fast Food

fastfoodNot long ago I wrote an article about a church that sent out a flier inviting people to their church based nothing more than the felt needs of the individual (Java, A Core Value).  It was a church where “the band is loud, and gallons of coffee are a core value.”  The idea here was to lay aside any fears one might have and see that the church was for regular people ( at least those considered regular in the Puget Sound region).  The invitation was laced with;  “ no perfect people allowed”, “ a place to be yourself, grow spiritually, build friendships, make a difference, and have a blast”, and  “its imperative to find and fulfill your unique purpose in life”.  This has become the common mantra of the Evangelical church under guise of evangelism. John MacArthur, writing on this phenomenon states; “That’s all great if you’re a coffeehouse.  But anyone who claims to be calling people to the gospel of Jesus with those priorities is calling them to a lie” (John MacArthur, “Hard to Believe”, Thomas Nelson Publishing, 2003, pg. 2).  A few pages later, commenting on Luke 9:23-26; “It’s pretty simple.  Anyone who wants to come after Jesus into the kingdom of God – anyone who wants to be a Christian – has to face three commands: 1) deny himself, 2) take up his cross daily, and 3) follow Him” (pg 6).  The point here is that the gospel of Jesus Christ is not about our personal fulfillment but one that calls us to self renunciation and to live to the honor and glory of God.  As a result of the above “man centered” form of evangelism and church growth, membership has exploded in many of these churches, especially targeting young adults, and have reaped congregations that know nothing or very little about self-denial and the Lordship of Christ in their lives. They have been taught that Christ came to save them from mediocrity so they “can be all they can be” and as a result have short circuited personal crucifixion (Romans 6).  We have announced  and proclaimed a gospel of grace that says “You don’t have to give up anything, just come as you are.” We have confused a “no works gospel” (Ephesians 2:8-9; Titus 3:5) with no repentance. The second half of the previous statement is manifestly true.  We must come as we are.  There is no self reformation or cleaning up that will stand before an infinitely holy and just God. But the first half of the statement is as equally false. You must die (Romans 6:1-11; John 12:24; Luke 9:24; 14:27; Galatians 2:19-20; 5:24; 6:14; Colossians 3:3; 1 Peter 2:24) and there is self denial (Matthew 5:3; 8:19-22; 16:24-25; Mark 10:21; Luke 9:23-26; John 12:25; Romans 8:12-13; 13:14; Philippians 3:7-10; 2 Timothy 2:4).  This kind of message has been called the “offense of the cross” (Galatians 5:12) because it denies any self righteousness and equally as certain, self-fulfillment.
Continue reading ‘Christianity – Fast Food’